The Midwest keeps delivering for luxury short-term rentals: strong drive-to demand, year-round reasons to visit, and acquisition costs that still pencil. Below are ten destinations where elevated design and smart positioning tend to outperform.
-
Lake Okoboji, Iowa
“Hamptons of the Heartland” vibes with a loyal summer crowd from Minneapolis, Omaha, and Sioux Falls. Lakefront access and polished, photo-ready design are the differentiators.
- Sweet spot: 3–5 bedrooms, docks/boat slips, sauna or hot tub for shoulder seasons
- Positioning: “Private lake basecamp” + pro photography + clear lake rules
- Check seasonal ADR/occupancy patterns
-
Black Hills, South Dakota (Deadwood • Custer • Spearfish)
Nature + nightlife + national icons. May–Oct books early; winter shoulder can perform with spa-style amenities.
- Design cues: Modern cabins, glass walls, indoor/outdoor fireplace
- Amenity move: Hot tub + sauna bundle to secure year-round demand
-
Brainerd Lakes, Minnesota
From fishing hub to upscale wellness-by-the-lake. Scandinavian-inspired interiors photograph and price well.
- All-season play: Fireplace, sauna, cold-plunge or outdoor shower
- Targeting: Repeat family groups + shoulder-season retreats
-
Door County, Wisconsin
Coastal charm, wineries, galleries. Boutique cottages and restored farmhouses lead revenue when thoughtfully staged and professionally shot.
- Walkability to town and water access matter
- Lean into chef’s kitchens + curated patio dining setups
-
Lake Geneva, Wisconsin
Chicago’s favorite lake escape. Competitive but worth it when product and photography are best-in-category.
- Differentiators: Waterfront, dock access, high-capacity dining & seating
- Expect stricter rules—plan compliance into underwriting
-
Traverse City, Michigan
Wine country meets lake life. Long tourist season anchored by events and resorts.
- Design: Light woods, lake glass, hotel-grade bedding
- Narrative: “Vineyard & bay retreat” with itinerary support
-
Galena, Illinois
Historic architecture + wedding and small-gathering demand. Walkable Main Street is gold.
- Upgrades that convert: Spa-like baths, private patios, carriage-house vibes
- Monetize with mid-week packages and micro-event positioning (within local rules)
-
Hocking Hills, Ohio
Cabin country with stunning sandstone gorges. Inventory that blends nature and architecture wins.
- High-ROI elements: Floor-to-ceiling glass, outdoor soaking tubs, stargazing decks
- Book-ahead culture—optimize minimum stays and dynamic pricing
-
Kansas City, Missouri (Plaza • Crossroads)
Urban luxury is maturing—design-forward townhomes/lofts serving leisure + business travel.
- Focus on gated parking, sound attenuation, and premium linens
- Corporate mid-week + event weekends = balanced calendar
-
Lake Poinsett, South Dakota
Quiet climber with strong weekend demand from Sioux Falls and regional drives. Lakefront renovations show attractive ROI without coastal price tags.
- Package: Dock, fire feature, four-season hot tub, gear storage
- Browse STR playbooks & owner guides
Owner Takeaways
- Design that photographs, sleeps well, and functions flawlessly outperforms “bigger but basic.”
- Wellness bundles (hot tub + sauna + cold plunge) extend seasonality in lake and forest markets.
- Drive-to convenience and walkability premiums are real—underwrite them.
Run the numbers on your next Midwest luxury STR
Get an owner-focused assessment and modeled returns for your market and property type.
